Thursday, April 28, 2011

Weekly 8 Rough Draft

            Romanesque and Gothic style buildings were big back then. It played a big part in the role of religious theology. A lot of buildings had religious views in them when they were being built. The buildings were also built in a style where if an invasion were to occur, the buildings would be a good source of protection from their tall towers, to the small arched windows. The buildings were not only a place of sanctity, but they were also a place of protection. The architecture of churches does not mean anything about theology.  
            The way that both structures were built was very noticeable. In Romanesque style cathedrals (figure 1) the inside of the building has no open windows, or glass. In gothic style cathedrals (figure 5) the inside of the building has stained glass and is very open unlike the Romanesque style. The Romanesque style building is more like that because the time period it was built was probably prone to multiple invasions so they had to have a means of protection so the cathedral was perfect. In the gothic style building there probably weren’t any invasions that were likely to happen so the building was more open and had windows, stained glass, etc.
            In just a simple comparison you can obviously tell which one is built for what type of scenario. In the Romanesque style (figure 2) it just looks like a place for defense. It has tall towers with no windows a perfect place for archers. In gothic style (figure 4) the building itself looks like it would be a place for tourist to visit the scenery looks good, it is nice and open with windows, and it doesn’t have towers that people can stand in. Just looking at the building it looks like it could be a stop on a tour if you were visiting.
            Even though they have their differences the two different styles of Romanesque styled cathedrals and Gothic styled cathedrals can also have their similarities. In (figure 3) the building has two large towers with windows so you can have a ranged attack. In figure (6) the building also has a similar type of build to it with the two towers. The windows in figure 3 are higher up so that is one of the differences between the buildings, and the windows in figure 6 are lower down not near the top like in the first image.
            Even though Romanesque and Gothic style cathedrals were built in different times they can still have similarities. The buildings were both a place for protection and a place for prayer and reflection. The interior of Romanesque style cathedral just proves that if build right, a place can be somewhere to worship and a place to go as a means of protection. Just because it looks like a fortress on the outside doesn’t mean it isn’t holy on the inside.


Figure 1http://www.worldofstock.com/slides/TEI1828.jpg
Figure 2
http://www.spanish-architecture.info/IMAGES/14-LeonCathedral.jpg
Figure 3
http://www.builders-resource.org/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/tournal-cathedral-in-belgium.
Figure 4
http://www.jayzine.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/8.jpg
Figure 5http://sp.life123.com/bm.pix/gothic-architecture3.s600x600.jpg
Figure 6
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhR5TA1DXjVTIiVH3r_Bd7uKhmBoAt_xdxTylcISnPNs_74DvgxedtX-v5caLPrI8VZeEm3OaKh-Zvb4za_YhC8rhsARh9gIc3OGeT4RdvHTmE5vRrtx4MOmj0ez3Q559PeMDk2gneFyLRi/









4 comments:

  1. yes you do
    not really
    yes
    yes
    yes
    yes
    none
    good
    no generalizations
    good
    good

    ReplyDelete
  2. 1. Yes
    2. Put more detail in your thesis statement to make it stronger.
    3. Correct in-text citations but you need to include the proper APA style under each picture.
    4. Include a little more analysis after each quote
    5. Conclusion does wrap up the paper
    6. I think strongest evidence is in 4th paragraph
    7. No personal pronouns are used
    8. Good academic tone without slang or contractions
    9. Good specific factual information used in the essay
    10. You might want to include more information in the essay
    11. You have original writing but more information would be helpful to this essay in general.

    ReplyDelete
  3. 1. 5 paragraphs,but not 5 sentences in each( Conclusion paragraph)

    2. Your thesis is present, but a little bit unclear.

    3.You did not do the citation for the pictures correctly.
    Ex. Notre Dame de Paris, facade, 13th century, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:060806-France-Paris-Notre_Dame.jpg, photograph taken in 2006.

    4. You need to include more sentences of analysis


    5. Your conclusion had a solid ending for the most part.

    6. Strongest evidence was in 4th paragraph.

    7. From what I saw, no personal pronouns.

    8. Use of academic tone- Yes

    9. Nice pictures

    10. Right amount of pictures

    11. Overall, you paper was pretty nice, but was lacking a few things.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Peer Review
    1. You have five paragraphs and five sentences.
    2. Not a very clear thesis, needs some more explanation.
    3. Proper in-text citations, but the citations under the pictures are not correct. Yo ushould fix them.
    4. Some paragraphs do not have four sentences of analysis, so you should go into more detail.
    5. Your conclusion needs some work.
    6. Your last body paragraph does not have the strongest evidence so switch it with one of your other paragraphs.
    7. You did a good job staying away from personal pronons.
    8. There is no slang or contractions, but some of the wording does not make sense.
    9. Some info is very specific but some of it is not.
    10.You had more info than quotes, but you could explain them a little more.
    11. This is from your honest voice, but this essay needs to be edited a lot more.

    ReplyDelete