Monday, March 21, 2011

week 4b daily 8

Could a force like Alexander the Great exist today? Why or why not?
            I think that a force like Alexander the Great’s could not exist today. Why? Because a lot of people wouldn’t do something a leader tells them to just because they are in a position of high authority. If a general told a private in the army to go kill someone that was a sergeant he would probably tell him no because it would not be right to kill off a fellow soldier like that. Not everyone would be following a tyrant like that if he was leading an army in the United States, but if you think about the situation in Iraq I would think that an army like that could exist because what the people in Iraq are doing is following a tyrant and doing whatever the leader tells them to no matter who’s lives it puts at risk. 

1 comment:

  1. This is a good response, and I like the track it's taking, but maybe you cold elaborate a bit more? Maybe talk about some specific instances where Alexander was seen as a tyrant who was not going to take no for an answer, and how that would have gone over in today's society. I agree with your view, I think it would be impossible to have such control over so much land at one time.

    ReplyDelete